Weeding the Web

RHS Chelsea 2016 - don't forget your oranges

So, for Chelsea Flower Show 2015 I pinpointed a warming of the colour palette with pinks, only to find most people commenting on the arrival of orange. Let's see what I can get wrong this year.

Actually, I stand by my opinion. There wasn't that much orange - not as much as this year, for sure. Though, this time it's dressing gardens in a whole range of tones from fruity bright to pastel soft and wandering into a sort of umber, with a backing chorus of furnishings and hard landscape.

Let's mix it up a bit and start with Artisan Gardens.

The Meningitis Now Futures Garden

This has plenty of orange because it's the brand colour of the charity. Designer John Everiss created the Evader's Garden last year, which told a strong, emotional story but relied heavily on the sculpture to create the garden. It was something he took to heart. As he took me through the planting this year, he said, "It's easy to fall into the trap where design overcomes planting, and we have to remember this is a flower show."

Orange is the signature colour of charity Meningitis Now.

The colour itself is part of the story. On the right, by the wall, it appears once. "An orange fleck," said John. "It represents the lightest touch, the point of contact with the charity, where they first offer support." Move over to the left-hand side and increasing orange represents an increasing level of contact, until - in a leap over the wall - there's loads of warm colour to contrast with the blues and purples left behind. This is where help is fully offered and "where you are enveloped in the charity".

The garden won Silver Gilt.

John Everiss has in no way lost his ability to narrate. By the time he'd explained the various figures, all created by Graham Chapelhow from 3D scans of children who have experienced meningitis and its grim consequences, I was totally in love with this garden.

Five-year-old Liam approaches the wall, not yet knowing he has meningitis (Liam himself has had meningitis a number of times), Gareth curls against the wall, unable to squeeze through (he died of the disease at sixteen). Lauren is struggling through the wall, reaching for help (Lauren herself recently set a new British Para-Cycling record) from Louise, who has reached the other side and survived meningitis (Louise is a member of the Irish Para-dressage team) and double-amputee Jake stands firm, staring into the future.

Gareth Rowlands, who died of meningococcal meningitis and septicaemia in 2003, imagined struggling against the barrier of the disease. On this side of the garden, the planting is blues and pinks.

If this were a garden in the real world, the walls would probably be around the edge, which would make a delightful design.

"People will stand and chat when you want a photo," I grumbled to someone who turned out to be from the Papworth Trust. "That's Joanna Trollope," she said, slightly shocked, "sponsor of the charity." John Everiss is on the left.

The AkzoNobel Honeysuckle Blue(s) Garden

Over in the Fresh Gardens (and surely the conceptual nature of the one above could have made it a shoo-in for this category, too), The Honeysuckle Blue(s) Garden was filled with plants originally used for dying. Calendula featured prominently.

The AkzoNobel Honeysuckle Blue(s) Garden was created by visual artist Claudy Jongstra in collaration with garden designer Stefan Jaspers. Won Silver-Gilt.

 The woad looked great against the dyed backdrop:

Woad creates a zing against the dyed backdrop.

What most preoccupied me at the time, though, was the impression that something large and furry had died in the middle of it:

The blue hanging on the back wall of the Honeysuckle Blue(s) Garden was created using natural dyes.

Sir Simon Moulton Urban Garden

Orange appeared in a rather different guise in Sir Simon Moulton Urban Garden, designed by Lee Bestall. The overwhelming injection of the colour came from the giant screen behind the plot and I don't think it did them any favours. Rather, it created a rather garish feel that wasn't their fault and overwhelmed the highlight dots of orange employed in the planting.

That orange was the ID colour for the Fresh Gardens and colour of choice for the text on all the information boards in that section. May I strongly suggest it's ditched next year? The boards - orange on grey - were an absolute pain to read.

Sir Simon Milton Urban Connections Garden. Won Silver.

External influence aside, this garden had another artificial source of orange in the bark of the silver birches.

Sir Simon Milton Urban Connections Garden, designed by Lee Bestall.

The idea is that the trees act as beacons to guide people to the oak seating, but actually it adds a bit of balance to all those purples. The colour is created by painting the bark with sunblock - which is used in Arizona to protect trees from the relentless rays which can crack bark and also to act as a mite repellant - into which has been mixed paprika extract.  "Yes," said Lee, "it will wash off."

The Modern Slavery Garden

And on the edge of Fresh Gardens (by the distant outpost of a tea tent which catches you just as you wonder if you'll survive further trekking) was The Modern Slavery Garden by Juliet Sargeant, there for the first time and winning Gold. She went for a mix of hot colours which combined in a fiery glow against the blacks of the Sintered Stone coping and edging, the charcoal mulch and the dark-leaved planting.

Modern Slavery Garden by Juliet Sargeant, used strong colours to counter the black.

I loved this garden - really strong colours and lines where the design wasn't overwhelmed by the message but underpinned it very well.

Flowers in the Modern Slavery Garden included Lupin 'Beefeater', Rosa 'Modern Slavery', Peony 'Coral Sunset', Euphorbia 'Fireglow' and Digitalis 'Suttons Apricot'. Overall a strong, powerful feel.

And the lupins looked good too:

I'm guessing not everyone would have liked the pinky apricot colours included.

The Garden of Mindful Living...

This Show Garden didn't employ flowers but, nevertheless, created an overall orange-y feel with seating, photo and corten steel.

Vestra Wealth's The Garden of Mindful Living, designed by Paul Martin. Won Gold.

The Telegraph Garden...

...displayed various hues.

Planting in the Telegraph Garden, designed by Andy Sturgeon. Won Gold.

Watahan East and West Garden...

... had this slightly strange mix of pinky-brown with orange.

The Watahan East and West Garden, designed by Yano TEA and Chimori Shibayana was awarded Silver.

Harrods British Eccentrics Garden...

...by Diarmuid Gavin, threw everything into the mix - I presume that represented eccentricity. Though, in view of some of the combinations above, I think the boat had sailed on that one.

Harrods British Eccentrics Garden won Silver-Gilt for Diarmuid Gavin.

Antithesis of Sarcophagi 

Finally, enough! As a complete contrast, here's one that didn't have any colour, let alone orange. 

The Marble and Granite Centre - Antithesis of Sarcophagi won Gold.

In fact, what the heck, maybe it did. Maybe inside that cube it was bursting with orange. Who knows? And, to be frank, who cares?

The only thing I like about this is the way the portico of the Chelsea Hospital building behind has blended with it in the photo to look as if they're joined, and that's serendipity.  This inside-out 'cleverness' has been done to death. Could we stop now, please?

Still, I've just noticed the man in the safety jacket...

Yup, orange.

 For more on Chelsea:

Who will win People's Choice, RHS Chelsea Flower Show 2016

The Personal Connection with Nature's Rhythms about The Papworth Trust garden (with video) (on Wireonwire.com)

Who will win People's Choice, RHS Chelsea Flower Show 2016?

So, 7.30 tonight and The People's Choice at Chelsea Flower Show will be announced. Who do you favour? Compared to last year, it seems less easy to pick obvious candidates. However, I'll go out on a limb here and say that I think Jo Thompson's Chelsea Barracks Garden is a good bet.

Jo Thompson's Qatari Diar Chelsea Barracks Garden. Won Gold. Copyright RHS. Credit: RHS/Neil Hepworth 

Lots of people don't like this, including garden critic Tim Richardson, who wrote in The Telegraph in his predictions for Best in Show (which he got spot on with tipping Andy Sturgeon's Telegraph Garden) that it was bewildering with a "curiously empty look", given the "bare island of lawn" in the middle.

When I bumped into him in front of this very garden, he wasn't showing any sign of changing his mind, and muttered darkly about "generic planting". But both of these are what I think might appeal. The lawn makes it feel familiar as a domestic garden and the planting was rich, frothy and full of colour.

Richly coloured planting by Jo Thompson.

There's also that lovely curve to the path - which I'd hazard is generally appealing. It wasn't without its build difficulties. The absolute precision of matching the curves of the specially imported basaltite paving with the steel edging was complicated by the large size of the pieces involved and dangers of flexing. But all that was overcome in a really gorgeous path, etched to represent ripples of the River Westbourne which runs beneath the original site of Chelsea Barracks.

The wall at the back is covered by a curtain of water.

When I passed on Monday, extra colour had been injected for a moment in front of that wall of water:

Designer Jo Thompson with a military band in The Chelsea Barracks Garden

It's possible that James Basson might snaffle the award this year. I suspect he came near the top of the list last year with his evocation of Provence, and this year's is every bit as evocative.

James Basson's L'Occitane Garden. Won Gold.

Diarmuid Gavin's English Eccentrics Garden also has crowd-pleasing ebullient planting.

Diarmuid Gavin's Harrods British Eccentrics Garden won Silver Gilt.

The overall impression is warmth and charm, but I think the gismos might be a step too far, and there's something a little too ersatz about the tower.

The British Eccentrics Garden by Diarmuid Gavin. Copyright RHS. Credit RHS/Sarah Cuttle.

Cleve West's M&G garden has the same sort of country appeal of L'Occitane Garden, but contrasted with modern sawn paving, balancing a full, busy naturalistic half...

Cleve West's M&G Garden. Won Gold.

...with a still, minimalist area that encouraged contemplation. That certainly seemed to be the effect on Dan Pearson who looked somewhat removed from the frenzy of Press Day:

Dan Pearson contemplates Cleve West's M&G Garden.

The more I looked at this, the more I enjoyed it. It was all the more fascinating for the fact that the huge beige-coloured boulders and the pale sawn paving were actually the same Forest of Dean sandstone. But from the outside it was difficult to really appreciate the water feature so I'm not sure this will win enough hearts. 

The M&G Garden is an evocation of Exmoor, where designer Cleve West spent his boyhood.

 

Finally, I have rather a soft spot for the Support, The Husqvarna Garden.

Support, The Husqvarna Garden, designed by Charlie Albone. Won Silver Gilt.

 

It hasn't caused much of a stir. Tim Richardson described it as the "standard Chelsea...formula" because it's mixing a formal structure and flouncy planting, but I liked it for the feeling that it would be an enjoyable garden to own. Seating at one end...

Setts created a more rustic feel in the seating area in contrast with the cantilevered shade.

 ...with a lovely view of the mixed tightly clipped and relaxed topiary (I'm a sucker for topiary), a lawn (ditto), and some unusual planting that made one stop and look closer.

Unusual planting added interesting texture to Charlie Albone's Support, The Husqvarna Garden.

This is, indeed, the one I would like to get the People's Choice award at Chelsea this year. On the whole, though, I suspect Jo Thompson has a better chance.

For a whizz round other gardens:

RHS Chelsea 2016 - don't forget your oranges

The Personal Connection with Nature's Rhythms  about the Papworth Trust Together We Can garden (on WireonWire.com)